Wastewater injection into underground injection control uic wells is understood to be the cause of earthquakes in oklahoma, though the spatial relationship between well locations and earthquakes is not exact. Abstract microseismicity induced by co2 injection at decatur, illinois, occurs. How large are the earthquakes induced by fluid injection. Usgs and its university partners have also deployed seismometers at sites of known or possible injectioninduced earthquakes in arkansas, southern colorado, oklahoma and ohio. Although natural earthquakes occur in many of these same areas e. Injection wells prone to induced seismic activity can be identi. A new study in the journal geology is the latest to tie a string of unusual earthquakes, in this case, in central oklahoma, to the injection of wastewater deep underground. Induced earthquakes accompanying the water injection. Cochran3 1conocophillips school of geology and geophysics, university of oklahoma, 100 e.
Characterization of induced seismicity patterns derived. Pdf anthropogenic fluid injections are known to induce earthquakes. May 09, 2018 many of the largest injection induced earthquakes have occurred along faults in basement rock beneath the target injection aquifers barbour et al. Although subtle differences in shaking between the two types had been observed, more research was. Murray, 2014 class ii underground injection control well data for 201020 by geologic zones of completion, oklahoma, pdf download holland, a. Because induced seismic events related to fluid injection are unpredictable, it has garnered more attention from the public. Drillinginduced earthquakes may endanger millions in 2016. In most cases such industrial activities do not stimulate earthquakes. Only a small fractionof these disposal wells have induced earthquakes that are large enough to be of concern to the public.
The model is based on the physical processes of fluid pressure and stress diffusion with triggering of the induced seismicity being controlled by coulomb friction. Humaninduced earthquak es have become an importan t topic of political and scien. Current understanding of induced seismicity in the united states. Ellsworth, william 20 injectioninduced earthquakes. The human induced earthquake database hiquake the human induced earthquake database hiquake is the largest and most uptodate database of earthquake sequences proposed to have been induced or triggered by human activity. November 12, 2014 released february 6, 2015, inducedseismicity. For example, injectioninduced earthquakes are thought to be responsible for the increase of earthquakes in some places, like oklahoma, which in 2014 experienced a greater number of earthquakes larger than magnitude 3 than california.
Earthquake magnitudes are primarily determined by the rupture area, i. Wastewater injection spurred biggest earthquake yet, says. This research measures the costs of induced seismicity through changes in home prices using a hedonic price analysis within a di erencesindi erences framework. Assessing causation requires combining seismicity information and disposal. In oklahoma, which has the most induced earthquakes in us, only 12% of the earthquakes can be linked to hydraulic fracturing operations. Combining the results of both boreholes, a linear approximation of the. Usgs and its university partners have also deployed seismometers at sites of known or possible injection induced earthquakes in arkansas, southern colorado, oklahoma and ohio. The humaninduced earthquake database hiquakethe humaninduced earthquake database hiquake is the largest and most uptodate database of earthquake sequences proposed to have been induced or triggered by human activity.
The standard model of injection induced seismicity considers changes in coulomb strength due solely to changes in pore pressure. Placing the problem in perspective nicholas deichmann, swiss seismological service, switzerland. Induced seismicity risk analysis of the hydraulic stimulation of a. Considering a hypothetical case in which only one well in a region is capable of inducing earthquakes, the epicenters of induced. Davis investigations concerning the nature of aftershocks and earthquakes induced by fluid injection, doctoral thesis, university of texas at austin 157 pp. Earthquakes continue for years after gas field wastewater injection stops, study finds. Pdf managing injectioninduced seismic risks researchgate. When compared with natural earthquakes, however, induced earthquakes are often shallower and might not shake the ground as violently far from the earthquakes epicentre. Mar 28, 2016 scores of papers on injectioninduced earthquakes were published in the geophysical literature in the following 40plus years, and the problem was well understood and appreciated by. Induced or triggered seismicity here taken to mean the same is a recognised hazard in practically all engineering. Potential injectioninduced seismicity associated with oil. We present the possibility of using these results in the operational reservoir to manage seismic hazards.
However, the sharp uptick in earthquake activity does not seem to be. The data are freely available to download in microsoft excel format for your own analysis. Sep 23, 2016 how large are the earthquakes induced by fluid injection. When a project is terminated, the rate of induced earthquakes diminishes with time, often. We investigate temporal variations in maximum magnitudes of induced earthquakes at the pvu using two methods. What work is the odnrdogrm doing to better understand the occurrence of injectioninduced earthquakes. For example, injection induced earthquakes are thought to be responsible for the increase of earthquakes in some places, like oklahoma, which in 2014 experienced a greater number of earthquakes larger than magnitude 3 than california. Energy technology activities known to have produced induced seismicity, whether significant enough to be felt by humans or so small as to be detected only with sensitive monitoring equipment, are fluid injection and withdrawal as well as purposeful fracturing of rocks. Therefore, wastewater injection can raise pressure levels more than enhanced oil recovery, and thus increases the likelihood of induced earthquakes. How does the injection of wastewater at depth cause earthquakes.
Earthquakes in unusual locations have become an important topic of discussion in both north america and europe, owing to the concern that industrial activity could cause damaging earthquakes. The number of anthropogenically induced earthquakes caused by deep underground operations, such as. Earthquakes induced by deep injection there has been a growing realization that the principal seismic hazard from injectioninduced earthquakes comes from those associated with disposal of wastewater into deep strata or basement formations 5. Wastewater injection spurred biggest earthquake yet, study. To estimate the maximum earthquake that could be induced by a given fluid injection project, the rock mass is assumed to be fully saturated, brittle, to respond to injection with a sequence of. Most injection wells are not associated with felt earthquakes.
Odnrdpgrm has deployed seismometers at sites of known or possible injectioninduced earthquakes in mahoning and washington counties, and has additional deployment planned to other counties with newly. We argue that, yes, small earthquakes do matter, and their interaction may be an important triggering mechanism to consider. Injection induced earthquakes have, in particular, become a focus of discussion as the application of hydraulic fracturing to tight shale formations is enabling the production of oil and gas from. Case study cases study on oilfield earthquake induced by. Both induced and natural earthquakes cause similar levels of ground shaking. Injectioninduced seismicity from class ii disposal wells. Summary the development of unconventional oil and natural gas resources using horizontal drilling and hydraulic fracturing has created new demand for disposal wells that inject waste fluids into deep geologic formations. For control and mitigation of induced seismicity, this document defines limits or triggers that, if activated, will initiate mitigation actions up to and including stopping injection and immediately flowing.
Induced earthquakes commonly occur several kilometers below the injection point. How does the injection of wastewater at depth cause. Not all wastewater injection wells induce felt earthquakes. There is growing evidence that wastewater injection can generate earthquakes under certain conditions.
Ellsworth, william 20 injectioninduced earthquakes, science 341, 1225942, doi. It has long been understood that earthquakes can be induced by impoundment of reservoirs, surface and underground mining, withdrawal of fluids and gas from the subsurface, and injection of fluids into. Injection induced earthquakes have, in particular, become a focus of discussion as the application of hydraulic fracturing to tight shale formations is enabling the production of oil and gas from previously unproductive formations. Given enough time, the injected fluids can migrate substantial horizontal and vertical distances from the injection location. Induced earthquakes are typically smaller size with less energy than tectonic earthquakes largest potentially injectioninduced earthquakes almost always occur in precambrian rock induced seismicity seems to be usually confined to shallow part of earths crust in vicinity of injection ground shaking levels are. Induced seismicity an overview sciencedirect topics.
Links between wastewater injection and the 2011 m w 5. Natural seismicity is usually assumed to be independent of time in assessing its hazard. Over the past few years injection induced seismicity iis has become an increasingly important issue that earth scientists working in the geothermal, mining, petroleum and other industries must. Jun 10, 2015 therefore, wastewater injection can raise pressure levels more than enhanced oil recovery, and thus increases the likelihood of induced earthquakes. Assessing the manner in which basement faults are likely to respond to pressure perturbations caused by fluid injection is. Induced seismicity is produced in a shale gas play area during a seismic survey and. High rates of injection and large volumes can perturb critically stressed faults, triggering earthquakes. Rupture propagation behavior and the largest possible earthquake induced by. Impressions toward induced seismicity are very different between different groups of people. Holloway 2014, multidisciplinary approach to identify and mitigate the hazard from induced seismicity in oklahoma, in amer. Earthquakes can be induced as part of the process to stimulate the production from tight shale formations. In this paper, we report on the seismicity change accompanying the water injection experiment, the migration of induced earthquakes, and physical properties of the nojima. Injectioninduced earthquakes have, in particular, become a focus of discussion as the application of hydraulic fracturing to tight shale formations is enabling the production of oil and gas from previously unproductive formations.
Similarly, disposal of flowback water after treatment and injection into abandoned deep wells also develops induced seismicity. The largest earthquake induced by fluid injection that has been documented in the scientific literature was a magnitude 5. Although induced seismicity related to underground injection activities was irst observed in the. The nojima fault is appropriate for monitoring its healing process because only a few years have passed since its last rupture.
In some cases, the induced earthquakes have been located as far as 10 km 6 mi. Many of the largest injectioninduced earthquakes have occurred along faults in basement rock beneath the target injection aquifers barbour et al. Of more than 150,000 class ii injection wells in the united states, roughly 40,000 are waste fluid disposal wells for oil and gas operations. Evans, institute of engineering geology, eth zurich, switzerland. A brief overview congressional research service 1 introduction humaninduced earthquakes, also known as induced seismicity, are an increasing concern in regions of the united states where the produced fluids and wastewaters from oil and natural gas. This report is developed by the statesfirst induced seismicity by injection work group. In this study we demonstrate a relationship between the 2011 oklahoma seismicity and. Seismicity induced by fluid injection, in contrast, varies with time, often because of changes in injection rate. Minimizing and managing potential impacts of injectioninduced. The remaining earthquakes are induced by wastewater disposal.
In the barnett shale play region, earthquakes occur near high volume injection disposal wells. Scores of papers on injectioninduced earthquakes were published in the geophysical literature in the following 40plus years, and the problem was well understood and appreciated by. A few sites regularly have larger quakes, such as the geysers geothermal plant in california which averaged two m4 events and 15 m3 events every year from 2004 to 2009. Rupture propagation behavior and the largest possible. Induced seismicity refers to typically minor earthquakes and tremors that are caused by human activity that alters the stresses and strains on the earths crust. Earthquakes continue for years after gas field wastewater. Most injection wells do not trigger felt earthquakes.
The estimate of maximum magnitude of induced earthquakes is difficult to constrain as, unlike naturally occurring earthquakes, the maximum magnitude of induced earthquakes changes over time and is affected by injection parameters. Pdf injection induced seismicity and geothermal energy. The seismic data was merged from university of bergen, british geological survey. This report discusses known cases of injectioninduced seismicity and how and why earthquakes may be triggered, as well as conditions under which the triggering is most likely to occur. The standard model of injectioninduced seismicity considers changes in coulomb strength due solely to changes in pore pressure. There have been limited studies into the role of earthquake interactions between the small. The data are freely available to download in microsoft excel format for your own analysis we endeavour to keep the database up to date and accurate. Gischig1 1swiss competence center for energy research sccersoe, eth zurich, zurich, switzerland. Maximum magnitude estimations of induced earthquakes at. This report discusses known cases of injection induced seismicity and how and why earthquakes may be triggered, as well as conditions under which the triggering is most likely to occur. The mechanisms involved are poorly understood, and our ability to assess the. Bardwell, some statistical features of the relationship between rocky mountain arsenal waste disposal and frequency of earthquakes, 3. Induced earthquakes are typically smaller size with less energy than tectonic earthquakes largest potentially injectioninduced earthquakes almost always occur in precambrian rock induced seismicity seems to be usually confined to shallow part of earths crust. A brief overview congressional research service 1 introduction human induced earthquakes, also known as induced seismicity, are an increasing concern in regions of the united states where the produced fluids and wastewaters from oil and natural gas.
In the eagle ford play region, earthquakes are not near injection wells, but follow increases in extraction of waterpetroleum. Injectioninduced earthquakes are thought to be caused by pressure changes due to excess fluid injected deep below the surface and are being dubbed manmade earthquakes. Plain language summary studies of the triggering mechanisms of injection. Injectioninduced earthquakes have, in particular, become a focus of discussion as the application of hydraulic fracturing to tight shale formations is enabling the production of oil and gas from.
Over the past few years injectioninduced seismicity iis has become an increasingly important issue that earth scientists working in the geothermal, mining, petroleum and other industries must. The result is a model that quantifies the distance that an earthquake can propagate beyond an injection sitewhich in turn predicts the maximum magnitude of an induced seismic event. Not all wastewater injection wells induce earthquakes. Fluid injection rates and volumes, fault orientations, accumulated stresses, and rock properties all need to be optimal to induce earthquakes. Evidence for subcritical rupture of injectioninduced earthquakes.
Earthquakes induced by human activities involving underground injection of fluids or gas are a growing concern, a hazard that needs to be controlled in order to. A brief overview may 12, 2015 open pdf 753 kb the development of unconventional oil and natural gas resources using horizontal drilling and highvolume hydraulic fracturing has created new demand for wastewater disposal wells that inject waste fluids into deep geologic strata. Induced earthquake bibliography injection induced earthquakes at the rocky mountain arsenal. Induced seismicity is only part of the chain reaction from industrial activities that worry the public. It has long been understood that earthquakes can be induced by impoundment of reservoirs, surface and underground mining, withdrawal of fluids and gas from the subsurface, and injection of fluids into underground formations.
469 185 766 708 1075 518 1404 834 312 445 823 1127 1482 1054 262 1117 1158 657 1279 483 1359 290 572 535 1091 1343 871 583 710 416 1145 894 758 1319 641 484 342 536 260 1064 855